Free Intensive Nov 21–22Free 2-day hands-on Vibecoding Intensive on Nov 21–22 at 16:00 MSK (Sat–Sun) · Live Cohort 3 starts Nov 23Join Free →Cohort 3 (Nov 23)
ReleaseInsight · On RadarTechCrunch→ original

How AI Startups Sell the Same Shares at Two Different Prices

Some AI startup founders are using a new valuation mechanism that lets them sell the same shares at two different prices. The scheme works by structuring funding rounds to artificially inflate a company's valuation to unicorn status. Some investors get preferential terms and protection against losses, while others pay a nominally high price that ends up in the headlines. The practice casts doubt on the real value of dozens of AI companies that have announced billion-dollar valuations over the past year.

AI-processed from TechCrunch; edited by Hamidun News
How AI Startups Sell the Same Shares at Two Different Prices
Source: TechCrunch. Collage: Hamidun News.
Listen to article

Unicorn status in the startup world stopped being rare a long time ago, but in artificial intelligence it has become something like a mandatory entry ticket. Without a billion-dollar valuation, it is hard to get press attention, lure top engineers and convince corporate customers that you are serious. Unsurprisingly, some AI founders have found a way to get the coveted status without waiting for the business to grow into it organically. According to TechCrunch, a growing number of AI startups are turning to an unconventional valuation mechanism in which the same shares are effectively sold at two different prices.

The mechanics are not new to the venture world, but it is in the AI industry that the scheme has become widespread. In essence: when raising a funding round, the company structures the deal so that some investors receive shares with built-in protection, such as guaranteed minimum returns, liquidation preferences or the right to convert on special terms. These privileges significantly reduce the investor's real risk, and therefore the effective price paid for the stake. Yet the press release and the paperwork show the nominal share price, without accounting for the value of all these "safety cushions." It is this inflated nominal price that is used to calculate the company's valuation, which then makes the headlines.

Imagine an apartment sold for ten million rubles, with the buyer also given a guarantee that the seller will buy it back at the same price in a year. The real cost of the deal to the buyer is considerably below ten million, because they risk practically nothing. But the land registry will still record ten million. That is roughly how the scheme works in venture capital, except that instead of an apartment it involves stakes in companies, and instead of a land registry, databases such as PitchBook and Crunchbase that the whole market relies on.

The practice raises serious questions on several levels. First, it blurs the very notion of a startup's valuation. When two investors in the same round effectively pay different prices for the same stake, which price reflects the company's real value? Second, it creates information asymmetry: employees who receive stock options go by the public valuation and may overestimate the value of their compensation. Prospective customers and partners make decisions based on figures that do not reflect economic reality. Third, if the practice becomes ubiquitous, it will undermine trust in the entire AI startup ecosystem, a market that already prompts fears of overheating.

Context is critical here. Over the past two years, the artificial intelligence sector has seen an unprecedented influx of capital. Dozens of companies have announced billion-dollar valuations, often at early stages and with minimal revenue. Investors gripped by fear of missing the "next OpenAI" have been willing to accept terms that would look absurd in any other industry. This overheated market created the ideal environment for creative valuation schemes to spread. When everyone wants to be a unicorn and investors are ready to turn a blind eye to the details, the line between ambitious positioning and manipulation gets blurry.

It is worth noting that formally, nothing about these schemes is illegal. Venture deals are private transactions between sophisticated investors, and everyone is free to structure them as they see fit. The problem is ethical and systemic. When a significant share of AI "unicorns" earned their status through financial engineering rather than real business growth, it builds a bubble of expectations that will sooner or later collide with reality. That collision may be especially painful for startup employees, whose options will turn out to be worth significantly less than they expected.

The venture industry is cyclical, and every market overheating breeds its own characteristic abuses. In the dot-com era it was IPOs of companies with no revenue; in the crypto era, tokens with phantom utility. Now the AI sector has its own mechanism for distorting reality. The question is not whether this bubble of inflated valuations will burst, but how painful the correction will be, and how many genuinely promising companies will suffer from the reputational damage inflicted by those who preferred financial engineering to actually building a business.

Story
ZK
Zhemal Khamidun — CPO at Alpina Digital, product manager of AlpinaGPT. Building AI products since 2019. Hamidun News is a pet project that grew into a production aggregator with 6,000+ readers.
✦ Private AI Builders Community · Vibe Club

Ship AI Faster with Founders, Engineers & Weekly Architecture Reviews

Inside Vibe Club (hamidun.com/club) — weekly live masterminds with Zhemal Khamidun, Tech Radar, full LMS access, and 370+ production Claude Code skills.

Join Vibe Club →Explore Hamidun Academy
What do you think?
Loading comments…