Free Intensive Nov 21–22Free 2-day hands-on Vibecoding Intensive on Nov 21–22 at 16:00 MSK (Sat–Sun) · Live Cohort 3 starts Nov 23Join Free →Cohort 3 (Nov 23)
ReleaseInsight · On RadarCNews ИИ→ original

27% of cybersecurity specialists call AI in defense an overhyped trend

27% of information security (InfoSec) specialists consider AI in defensive products an overhyped trend, according to a survey by Kontur.Egida and Staffcop. At the same time, 34% are convinced that AI-driven attacks grew faster and at a larger scale in 2026 than they expected. In other words, attackers are taken seriously, while "AI-powered defense" in products is seen by many as marketing. So when choosing a solution, ask for the numbers: how many attacks it caught and how many false alarms it removed.

AI-processed from CNews ИИ; edited by Hamidun News
27% of cybersecurity specialists call AI in defense an overhyped trend
Source: CNews ИИ. Collage: Hamidun News.
Listen to article
Article Fact Sheet & Key Figures
ParameterDetails
Primary sourceCNews ИИ ↗
Editor-in-Chief
36% were surprisedInfoSec budgets were cut more deeply in 2026 than expected
Key metric #2If the budget is cut by a third, 58% would protect the team first
203 people surveyed107 from customer companies, 84 from vendors

27% of information security (InfoSec, meaning the protection of companies from breaches and leaks) specialists consider the use of artificial intelligence in defensive products an overhyped trend. That is the finding of the study "InfoSec on the Threshold of 2027" by Kontur.Egida and Staffcop. The survey covered 203 people, and the company passed the results to CNews. Put simply, roughly one in four security professionals sees the loud label "AI-based protection" as marketing rather than real value. If you choose defensive products or build them yourself, this is a useful snapshot of the mood among the people who will be your buyers.

What the survey showed about AI

The headline figure, 27%, is the one highlighted in the title. For comparison, other "overheated" topics scored lower. Only 10% of respondents called AI attacks overhyped, and another 10% said the same about single-vendor ecosystems (when all protection is bought from one manufacturer).

The threat from AI is not being dismissed. 34% of respondents believe that AI-driven attacks developed faster and on a larger scale in 2026 than they had expected. A quarter of those surveyed (25%) think that attackers' use of AI will become one of the main factors affecting security in 2027. Most often, respondents pointed to regulatory requirements on this question: 40% named them.

The picture is fairly candid. Attackers are using AI, and this is visible in practice. But many people still regard AI built into defensive products as a promise without measurable results.

Money: budgets are being cut, and the team is protected

For 36% of respondents, the main surprise of 2026 was that information security budgets were cut more sharply than they had expected. Forecasts for next year differ between customers and suppliers:

  • Among customers, 40% expect their InfoSec budget to grow, and 22% expect it to shrink;
  • Among vendors and other participants, 40% forecast that their clients' budgets will shrink, and 26% forecast growth.

If funding were cut by a third, the largest share of participants (58%) would try to keep the specialist team intact. Security monitoring came next. Backup and recovery was chosen by 25%, web service protection by 23%, and account and access protection by 17%. Among customers expecting a budget cut, 19 of 24 (79%) chose the team, and among those expecting growth, 24 of 42 (57%) did. The authors themselves note that the groups are small and that this comparison does not characterize the market as a whole.

High-profile incidents do not always loosen purse strings either. Only 7% of participants received additional money after resonant attacks. Another 20% accelerated InfoSec projects within the existing budget, and the same share reported that management requested a readiness report or organized drills.

Why defensive solutions are changed reluctantly

The most common reasons for replacing an already deployed solution are the manufacturer ceasing development of the product (33%) and an incident caused by its shortcomings (26%). Only 17% cited the possibility of saving more than 30%. A representative of Kontur explains this: switching to a new product takes time for deployment, staff training and reworking processes, and it also carries the risk of errors and a temporary drop in protection. That is why companies hold on to systems that work, especially those deeply embedded in their IT infrastructure.

What this means in practice

First, startups and vendors selling "AI-powered protection" will have to prove its value with numbers: more attacks caught, shorter response times, fewer false positives. The "AI" label alone already triggers skepticism among a notable share of professionals. Second, under tight budgets, customers are investing in people and monitoring rather than new fashionable layers of defense. An AI tool has to pay for itself by relieving the team, not by replacing it.

Caveats are needed. The survey covered 203 people: 107 from customer companies, 84 from suppliers of InfoSec solutions and services, and 12 from other categories. The survey ran on October 27–28, 2026, and its organizers themselves work in the InfoSec products market. These are the opinions of specialists, not measurements of how effective AI security tools are. As a mood indicator the sample is useful, but it is not a basis for a procurement strategy. It is better to run your own pilot and see what the AI features actually deliver in your infrastructure.

Story

Key Questions Answered

What the survey showed about AI?

The headline figure, 27%, is the one highlighted in the title. For comparison, other "overheated" topics scored lower. Only 10% of respondents called AI attacks overhyped, and another 10% said the same about single-vendor ecosystems (when all protection is bought from one manufacturer). The threat from AI is not being dismissed. 34% of respondents believe that AI-driven attacks developed faster and on a larger scale in 2026 than they had expected.

What are the key details on Money: budgets are being cut, and the team is protected?

For 36% of respondents, the main surprise of 2026 was that information security budgets were cut more sharply than they had expected. Forecasts for next year differ between customers and suppliers: Among customers, 40% expect their InfoSec budget to grow, and 22% expect it to shrink; Among vendors and other participants, 40% forecast that their clients' budgets will shrink, and 26% forecast growth. If funding were cut by a third, the largest share of participants (58%) would try to keep the specialist team intact.

Why defensive solutions are changed reluctantly?

The most common reasons for replacing an already deployed solution are the manufacturer ceasing development of the product (33%) and an incident caused by its shortcomings (26%). Only 17% cited the possibility of saving more than 30%. A representative of Kontur explains this: switching to a new product takes time for deployment, staff training and reworking processes, and it also carries the risk of errors and a temporary drop in protection.

ZK
Zhemal Khamidun — CPO at Alpina Digital, product manager of AlpinaGPT. Building AI products since 2019. Hamidun News is a pet project that grew into a production aggregator with 6,000+ readers.
✦ Unified AI Workspace · Nomad

Test Frontier LLMs & Autonomous Agents in One Workspace

Run Claude Opus 5.5, GPT-6, Gemini 3.1, and DeepSeek side-by-side in Nomad AI (nomadnet.ai) — unified model routing, deep research, and multimodal workflows under one subscription.

Try Nomad AI →Launch Nomad Agent
What do you think?
Loading comments…